[유튜브 리뷰][문복희 Eat with Boki] 신전떡볶이 영상의 “혼자 아니야” 소리에 대한 영상 분석 결과입니다

(추천)인기 동영상 : [문복희 Eat with Boki] 신전떡볶이 영상의 “혼자 아니야” 소리에 대한 영상 분석 결과입니다

 

이번에는 유튜브 인기 동영상에 대해서 리뷰해보겠습니다.

요즘에는 다들 유튜브 볼때 좋은 내용의 영상이더라도 영상이 너무 길면 건너뛰기 하거나, 안보게 되는 경우가 있습니다.

혹시 인터넷 뉴스나 유튜브를 볼때 스크롤해서 댓글 먼저 보시는 분들 많으신가요?

바쁜 현대인들의 시간절약을 위해서 유튜브 인기 동영상의 중요 내용이나 요약, 공감 댓글 등을 먼저 확인해보고 유튜브를 시청해보는건 어떨까요?

(추천)인기 동영상 : [문복희 Eat with Boki] 신전떡볶이 영상의 “혼자 아니야” 소리에 대한 영상 분석 결과입니다

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J-Jo4CGIN3Y

 

---

 

요약 댓글 : [문복희 Eat with Boki] 신전떡볶이 영상의 “혼자 아니야” 소리에 대한 영상 분석 결과입니다

최세*:

For those looking for a full summary and explanation on why Boki is being criticized :

So basically she is involved in 4 problems :

1. hiding and lying to her viewers about the fact that a video/ food was sponsored (this violates Youtube guidelines and is illegal in Korea)

2. spitting out food while pretending to eat a huge amount of food (which is a huge part of why so many people watch her). People started pointing this out to her, but she never gave an official statement. Instead, she told her viewers she would start releasing full versions of her videos (probably to indirectly show us that she doesnt spit her food out). However, in these videos we see some strange points, as they remain heavily edited (but discreetly, we can clearly see thay shes trying to make this all look natural and look like an "unedited" version.). Some examples are food changing positions, or the amount of food decreasing between video frames.

3. telling people that she works alone, and is not part of a company. she claimed she films videos for her own pleasure and because she loves food. She even had a video of her eating porridge, after claiming "she was sick and couldn't go to the studio (where she usually films), and was therefore eating at home". (this was later proved to be an ad for the porridge btw)

4. english translation and comments



Here's whats going on :

1. She admitted and apologized for lying about the ads (hiding the fact that they were ads). When this whole scandal happened and affected a huge part of the Korean YT community, she denied the fact that she lied about ads and said "If i filmed videos to earn money i would film a commercial or go on a tv show. I only film to share my love for food so there is no way i would lie to you".

= she admitted she lied. this is the FIRST LIE.

2. She uploaded this video trying to show viewers how she works and trying to clear some misunderstandings on the "strange points" mentioned earlier (food changing positions etc). We can indeed see that she does not spit her food out and the strange points were proved to be due to her trying to get a better angle on the food, taking breaks or fixing her makeup.

HOWEVER, the videos she released are the latest videos, which were filmed AFTER she promised to show us the full versions at the end. Korean viewers are therefore freaking out again because she does not show the full versions of the previous videos (before promising to show us the full versions. what does this mean ? in all the videos filmed after this point she has no choice but to force herself to eat everything because she promised to release the full versions). She therefore PURPOSELY included her most recent videos as they are most likely the only ones where she actually swallows her food. Of course, this proves that she may have quit spitting out her food, but does not prove that she didn't do it all. If she is unable to provide real proof (especially regarding her previous videos), this is her SECOND LIE (because clearly the video was made to show us thay she does not spit out her food).

3. Though she claimed she worked alone without staff, this video proved the contrary. Throughout the video, if you increase the decibell, you can hear people directing her ("put that food there." "eat that." "smile." "put more lipstick on".). Not only did this piss her viewers off because it proved that everything was planned, directed and "fake", but also because this is the THIRD LIE.

4. She is known for communicatimg with her international fans too, providing translation for her descriptions. However, in her videos or posts talking about the ads and especially her apology post, the translation is nowhere to be seen. People are therefore clashing her because she purposely does not put english translation to hide all of this from her foreign fans (which are a huge part of her fanbase). And when she talks about her being innocent and such she immediately puts back the english version. Also, she deletes comments talking about her scandals (especially the spitting out one) and on this video people claim she is deleting english comments explaining her wrongdoings (usually comments that Koreans put to bring awareness and to telll foreign viewers the truth), again, to hide all of this from her foreign viewers (theyre most likely the only ones keeping her from completely losing all her subscribers and subscribers = ). This is the FOURTH LIE (a lie because she is purposely trying to decieve her viewers).

외국인들이 이해할수있게 정리 해봤습니다. 이슈 유투버들 및 댓글들 바탕으로 적은거니 수정하거나 틀린말있으면 알려주세요 ! (복붙중)

 

---

 

재생시간 댓글 : [문복희 Eat with Boki] 신전떡볶이 영상의 “혼자 아니야” 소리에 대한 영상 분석 결과입니다

문복************:

안녕하세요 복희예요 !

저의 영상 중 신전떡볶이 먹방영상(https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WQK36RBTia4) 에서 1:47에 “혼자 아니야” 라고 말하는 듯한 여자의 말소리가 들린다는 댓글이 많이 달렸더라구요

많은 분들이 무슨 소린지 궁금해 하셔서 소리를 분석하는 전문기관에 의뢰를 했는데 조금 전에 결과가 나왔어요 !
게시글로 올리려고했는데 스펙토그램으로 분석된 주파수 그래프를 보여드리는게 좋을 것 같아서 영상으로 올립니다 !

성문분석 결과 ““혼자 아니야”라고 들리는 것으로 의심되는 청취 구간에서 성문이 관찰되지 않고, 청취 구간에 대해 음절 단위로 분석했을 때에 ‘혼’과 같은 소리로 청음되지 않는다. 따라서 의심되는 청취 구간은 사람이나 다른 목소리일 가능성이 매우 낮다“이라는 소견을 받았습니다.  

따라서 해당부분은 “음식물을 씹고 삼키는 소리와 숨소리가 겹쳐서, 소리가 증폭되는 ASMR의 특성에 의해 녹음이나 편집과정에서 발생된 소리 같다”는 의견이었습니다

복덩희들의 궁금증이 조금이라도 풀렸으면 좋겠어요 그럼 더욱 맛있는 영상으로 만나요

김주*:

0:15 협찬협찬협찬협찬

fa****:

translation:




Hello, this is Bokhee!


In my video, there was a lot of comments that I heard the voice of a woman who seemed to say "I'm not alone" at 1:47 in the Shinjeon Tteokbokki Meokbang video (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WQK36RBTia4).


Many of you were wondering what I was talking about, so I turned to a professional organization that analyzes sounds, but the results came out a while ago!
I tried to post it, but I think it would be better to show the frequency graph analyzed by the spectrogram, so I upload it as a video!


As a result of analyzing the voiceprint, the voiceprint is not observed in the listening section suspected of hearing “I am not alone,” and when the listening section is analyzed in syllable units, it is not heard with a “horn” -like sound. Therefore, the suspected listening section is very unlikely to be a human or other voice. ”


Therefore, the relevant part was the opinion that “the sound of chewing and swallowing food and the sound of breath overlapped, and the sound is amplified by the characteristic of ASMR, which is the sound generated during the recording or editing process”


I hope that the curiosity of Bok Dung Hee will be solved even a little Then see you in a more delicious video

Do********:

0:18 뭐하는거냐

윱*:

0:37 분쨔 분쨔 분쨔
다음은 분쨔를 포함한 베트남 음식 먹방 가시죠~

가족*:

0:36 협찬 ㄷㄷ

li**********:

0:13 really sounds like i'm digging dirt it minecraft. you can't tell me i'm not right

승*:

0:37
혼자
금자
톤자
훈자
쿵짜
호이짜
큼짜
풍자
홍차
끔짜

김범*:

0:17 ㄹㅇ 이건 마인크래프트다

Ai***********:

To anyone looking for the english explanation of this vid, here is an english translation of boki's pinned comment:


Hello, this is Bok-hee!

My video extension Tteokbokki muk-bang video (either from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WQK36RBTia4) 1:47 "not alone" in that it sounds like the voices of women telling the deoraguyo ran a lot of comments and

a lot of people I was curious about what you were talking about, so I asked a professional agency to analyze the sound, but the result came out a while ago!
I tried to post it as a post, but I think it would be better to show the frequency graph analyzed by the spectogram, so I upload it as a video!

As a result of the voiceprint analysis, the voiceprint is not observed in the listening section that is suspected to be heard as “I am not alone”, and when the listening section is analyzed in syllable units, it is not heard with a sound like'soul'. Therefore, it is very unlikely that the suspected listening section is a human or other voice.”

Therefore, this part was the opinion that “the sound of chewing and swallowing and the sound of breathing overlaps, and it is like the sound generated during the recording or editing process due to the characteristics of ASMR that amplifies the sound.”

Then let's see a more delicious video

 

---

 

인기순 댓글 : [문복희 Eat with Boki] 신전떡볶이 영상의 “혼자 아니야” 소리에 대한 영상 분석 결과입니다

잉*:

사실 복희언니가 젤 무서웠을듯ㅋㅋㅋㅋ

이지*:

언니 논란 터질 때만 한글로 쓰고 너무해~~영어로도 해명해야지??

세종******:

그 씹는 소리 녹음할때 같이 된거같은데.ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 먹뱉좀 그만해라.ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

성*:

라이브 통해서 직접 드시는 모습 보고 싶네요

박예*:

헉 뭔가 무섭 소리반복하니까ㄷㄷ 그래도 이상한 소리가 아니라니 다행이네용ㅋㅋ

송우*:

진짜 개뿔도 중요하지않은거는 이렇게 마치 뭐 있는듯이 칼같이 동영상 올리면서, 진짜 본질인 풀영상은 왜 안올렸나 싶다.

프로*******:

최근 영상보니까 이거 옆에서 지시해주는(?) 피디분 목소리일지도..모르겠네요

뇸*:

귀신의 고자질이네 ㅋㄱㅋㅋㄱㅋㅋ 혼자 아니야: 구독자들아 얘 혼자아니야 광고와 함께야

솜풍**:

먹뱉 해명이랑 뒷광고 해명 사과영상이라도 좀 올려 다른 유튜버들은 올리는데 넌 왜 안올려 ?

응*:

ㅇㄴ 그 전에 들어봤을땐 그냥 뭐지 이러고 넘겼는데 이렇게 자세히 들어보니까 왜 더 무섭냐;;

토*:

근데 혼자 아니야 라는 소리가났다고 하더라도
왜 이게 논란이 될일인가??
소리가 날 수도있지..
참 사람들 별일가지고 다 논란일으키네

인투********:

진짜 혼자 아니었네 광고가 함께 하니까

민*:

이걸 이렇게 분석하다니 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 루머있으면 보통 "헉 진짜네 뭐지?" 이러고 넘어가지 않나 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ? 알다가도 모를 보키언니

왕*:

진짜 혼자가 아니었네ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

동*:

협찬 아니야 협찬 아니ㅑ

Do********:

이거 아무도 해명 안바렜는데

태*:

진짜 혼자가아니었네 스텝목소리였어...ㄷㄷ

Cu*********************:

Others: got scared

Me: don't understand anything

스*:

설마 이거 먹뱉 도와주던 스탭 목소리 아니야?

흙*:

이거 소리갖다붙히면서 중간에 다른소리 끼었을 확률 나는 무조건 있다고 본다.

fo******:

보는 내가 다 낯뜨겁다ㅋ 스태프인 게 만천하에 밝혀졌네?ㅋㅋㅋ 거짓말은 거짓말을 낳고...갈수록 수습불가

Mi***:

I just woke up when I saw this and I thought Boki posted morse code

악*:

설마 음식물 쓰레기 봉투 소리는 아니겠지?...

김민*:

협찬으로 들리는 분들 있는 거 같아서 신전 영상 다시 보고 왔는데 걔는 광고표시가 안 붙었더라구요. 협찬이냐고 물어본 거에 대해 답한 목소리가 들어간 게 아닐까 하는 생각이 듭니다. (혼자 아니야가 아니라 협찬 아니야가 맞지 않나 하는??) 이렇게 된다면 협찬을 받는다는 걸 복희님도 모르고 계셨을 수도 있다고 생각하고 싶지만 추측이 맞다면 충격일 것 같습니다....

겅*:

혼자아니야가 아니라 ' 언제 하냐 '아님 ??

Ha***:

전문가에게 의뢰한게 아니라 좋문가에게 의뢰한건가 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 진짜 혼자가 아니었네?

Le****:

Still gonna watch her mukbang without sound.

송하*:

나만? 협찬이야 이케들림 ?

Fr*******:

???:뒷광고 나만했나?
문복희:혼자 아니야

 

---

 

[문복희 Eat with Boki] 인기 동영상에 대해서 댓글들을 모아 요약형, 시간대형, 인기순 등으로 알아보았습니다.

좋은 영상 혹은 채널인데, 너무 길어서 아쉬웠던 분들은 유튜브 채널이나 동영상 링크를 남겨주시면 블로그 포스팅해드리겠습니다.

 

---